Hakem Rehberi
Reviewers play a key role in maintaining the quality of JIArcS. The journal uses a double-blind review process: the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to each other.
Before accepting an invitation
- Accept only if the manuscript is within your expertise and you can complete the review on time (normally within 3 weeks).
- Decline if you have a conflict of interest or think you can identify the authors.
What to evaluate
Reviews are completed online using the JIArcS Reviewer Form, which covers:
- Originality and relevance to the journal's scope
- Whether the title, abstract and keywords reflect the content
- Compliance with scientific and ethical rules, and whether ethics committee approval is needed
- Clarity of the introduction and aims
- Appropriateness of the methodology, data analysis and findings
- Discussion of findings with relevant literature; adequacy of references
- Support of conclusions by the findings
- Language, grammar and spelling; quality of figures and tables; overall readability
Recommendation
Please choose one of: Accept, Minor revision, Major revision or Reject. Write comments for the authors that are specific and constructive, and add confidential notes for the editor where needed. Indicate whether you wish to see the revised version.
Confidentiality and ethics
- Treat the manuscript as confidential; do not share it or use its content.
- Do not use generative AI tools to evaluate or upload the manuscript.
- Report any suspected plagiarism, data manipulation or ethical concern to the editor.