Ethical Principles and Publication Policy
JIArcS follows the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) Scientific Research and Publication Ethics Directive and the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). All parties involved in the publication process — authors, editors and reviewers — are expected to comply with the principles below.
Responsibilities of authors
- Submitted work must be original, must not have been published before, and must not be under review elsewhere.
- All authors must have contributed substantially to the work and approved the final version. Contributions must be stated in the Author Contribution Statement.
- All sources must be cited properly. Copyright of texts, figures and documents belonging to others must be respected and permissions obtained where needed.
- Conflicts of interest and funding sources must be declared.
- Where required, ethics committee or legal/special permissions must be obtained and reported with the institution, date and decision number.
- The scientific, ethical and legal responsibility for an article belongs to its authors.
Research and publication misconduct
Plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, salami slicing, unjustified authorship and failure to acknowledge contributors are considered unethical. Manuscripts with a similarity rate above 20% are not accepted for review. Suspected misconduct is handled in line with COPE flowcharts; confirmed cases may lead to rejection or retraction.
Use of generative artificial intelligence
Authors must comply with TÜBİTAK's Guide to the Responsible and Trustworthy Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence. Any use of generative AI at any stage of research, writing or editing must be disclosed clearly in the article. AI tools cannot be listed as authors.
Responsibilities of editors
- Evaluate manuscripts solely on their scientific merit, originality and relevance to the scope, without regard to the authors' identity, institution, nationality or beliefs.
- Keep submitted manuscripts and reviewer identities confidential.
- Avoid conflicts of interest; manuscripts submitted by editors are handled by another editor and reviewed under the same double-blind process.
- Publish corrections, retractions or expressions of concern when necessary.
Responsibilities of reviewers
- Review objectively, constructively and within the requested time.
- Keep the manuscript confidential and do not use its content for personal benefit.
- Decline the review in case of a conflict of interest.
- Inform the editor of any suspected plagiarism or ethical problem.
Complaints and appeals
Complaints and appeals regarding editorial decisions or ethical issues can be sent to the editorial office through the Contact page. Each case is reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief and, where necessary, the editorial board.